Types of Feedback (with Examples) Every Leader Should Excel At
Jul 15
/
Language of Leadership
Feedback is one of the most misunderstood tools in leadership. Too often, it's treated like a formality. Something you offer once a quarter, or say to check a box. But in reality, the different types of feedback you give as a leader are one of the most powerful ways to help your team grow.
If someone on your team is struggling and you haven’t given them clear, actionable feedback, you're quietly reinforcing the very behavior you're frustrated with. People don’t usually change just because you set a good example or introduce a new incentive. They change when someone takes the time to be specific about what needs to shift and why it matters.
Feedback isn’t about venting. It’s not about relieving your own frustration. It’s about helping someone see something they couldn’t see on their own and giving them the clarity to do something different.
That clarity pays off. A study by Gallup found that 80% of employees who receive meaningful feedback weekly are fully engaged at work.
When it’s done well, feedback leads to engagement, productivity, and progress. It helps people improve how they show up, how they think, and how they contribute. It’s one of the most direct ways to create meaningful change on a team.
The more comfortable you get with giving different types of feedback in a range of situations, the more effective you become at leading people through uncertainty, growth, and complexity.
If someone on your team is struggling and you haven’t given them clear, actionable feedback, you're quietly reinforcing the very behavior you're frustrated with. People don’t usually change just because you set a good example or introduce a new incentive. They change when someone takes the time to be specific about what needs to shift and why it matters.
Feedback isn’t about venting. It’s not about relieving your own frustration. It’s about helping someone see something they couldn’t see on their own and giving them the clarity to do something different.
That clarity pays off. A study by Gallup found that 80% of employees who receive meaningful feedback weekly are fully engaged at work.
When it’s done well, feedback leads to engagement, productivity, and progress. It helps people improve how they show up, how they think, and how they contribute. It’s one of the most direct ways to create meaningful change on a team.
The more comfortable you get with giving different types of feedback in a range of situations, the more effective you become at leading people through uncertainty, growth, and complexity.
Why Leaders Should Excel at Many Types of Feedback
If you lead people, your ability to give feedback is one of the most effective tools you have. When it’s missing or unclear, people stay stuck. They repeat the same mistakes. They make assumptions. And often, they stop trying to improve.
Some leaders avoid feedback because it feels uncomfortable. Others give it to check a box or to prove that they’ve “dealt with” an issue. Neither approach helps anyone get better. The real purpose of feedback is to give someone the clarity and direction to make a meaningful change. That might be a shift in behavior, a better process, or a more productive mindset.
For feedback to work, it needs to be direct, timely, and relevant to the person receiving it. If it’s too vague or too late, it won’t land. But when it’s specific and useful, it gives people a real opportunity to take ownership of their growth.
That goes for positive feedback, too. If someone runs a great meeting, writes a strong report, or handles a tough situation well, say something. Let them know specifically what worked and why. Reinforce what you want to see more of.
As a leader, you are always sending a message. If someone does something well and hears nothing, that silence communicates something. If someone continues an unhelpful pattern and you say nothing, that communicates something too. You’re either reinforcing a helpful behavior or allowing a problem to continue.
Leadership isn’t about silence. It’s about being clear, supportive, and willing to speak up when it matters.
Different Types of Feedback Explained
As a leader, you’re going to give a lot of different types of feedback. Some of it will be formal. Some of it will be off-the-cuff. Some will focus on how someone is progressing over time, and some will be about a single moment. It doesn’t matter what label you put on it. What matters is knowing when and how to use each type effectively.
The most powerful feedback is informal and frequent. It's natural. It's helpful. It's the kind of thing you say to someone because you genuinely want them to succeed. Think about the last time someone gave you advice that made you better at something, like fixing your car, coaching a team, or leading a meeting. That’s what we’re after. Something useful and specific, shared in a way the person can hear it.
Now, there are times when feedback needs to be formal. Maybe there’s a legal or HR reason. Maybe your company’s process requires it. That’s fine, and it’s important to do it right. But don’t confuse formality with effectiveness. The more formal the process gets, the easier it is for the message to lose its power. Too many leaders hide behind performance reviews or scripted talking points and never actually say the thing the person needs to hear.
Here’s the general rule: feedback should be as informal and frequent as possible, and as formal and structured as necessary. If the goal is to help someone grow, your focus should be on clarity and relevance, not paperwork.
There’s also feedback that happens in the moment, like when you notice someone doing something well or falling into a pattern that needs to shift. That kind of feedback can be formative, guiding someone while they’re still learning. Other times, you’re evaluating a result after the fact, which might be more summative. Again, the labels aren’t the point. The impact is.
Whatever type of feedback you're giving, it needs to be meaningful to the person receiving it. That’s what makes it land. If they can see how the feedback helps them grow, improve, or reach their goals, they’ll be much more likely to take it seriously.
The most powerful feedback is informal and frequent. It's natural. It's helpful. It's the kind of thing you say to someone because you genuinely want them to succeed. Think about the last time someone gave you advice that made you better at something, like fixing your car, coaching a team, or leading a meeting. That’s what we’re after. Something useful and specific, shared in a way the person can hear it.
Now, there are times when feedback needs to be formal. Maybe there’s a legal or HR reason. Maybe your company’s process requires it. That’s fine, and it’s important to do it right. But don’t confuse formality with effectiveness. The more formal the process gets, the easier it is for the message to lose its power. Too many leaders hide behind performance reviews or scripted talking points and never actually say the thing the person needs to hear.
Here’s the general rule: feedback should be as informal and frequent as possible, and as formal and structured as necessary. If the goal is to help someone grow, your focus should be on clarity and relevance, not paperwork.
There’s also feedback that happens in the moment, like when you notice someone doing something well or falling into a pattern that needs to shift. That kind of feedback can be formative, guiding someone while they’re still learning. Other times, you’re evaluating a result after the fact, which might be more summative. Again, the labels aren’t the point. The impact is.
Whatever type of feedback you're giving, it needs to be meaningful to the person receiving it. That’s what makes it land. If they can see how the feedback helps them grow, improve, or reach their goals, they’ll be much more likely to take it seriously.
Constructive Feedback Meaning for Leaders
Let’s talk about what constructive feedback actually means. The phrase gets thrown around a lot, but in practice, it’s about helping someone solve a problem they may not even realize they have. It’s not just pointing out what’s wrong. It’s showing someone a better way to move forward.
Here’s a simple definition of constructive feedback: It’s feedback that helps someone improve by making a meaningful change. That change might be in how they handle a situation, how they prepare, how they make decisions, or how they carry themselves in the role. What matters is that it leads somewhere.
I had a guy on my team named Jake who used to rely heavily on me for high-level sales conversations. He’d ask me to join his meetings, and for a while, I did. Eventually, I realized he didn’t actually need me there. He was capable. He just hadn’t built the confidence yet.
So I told him, “You’re able to make most of the decisions I would make in these conversations. Let’s talk about the ones where you might still need backup. And if you get stuck, let’s come up with a plan for how you’ll handle it.”
That was constructive feedback. I wasn’t telling him what he was doing wrong. I was helping him realize what he was ready for and showing him how to take the next step on his own. It was about shifting him from dependence to ownership.
Constructive feedback should feel like support, not correction. It should point toward possibility, not just critique the past. And it needs to be delivered in a way that the other person can receive. That doesn’t always mean staying neutral or soft. It means being thoughtful about how the message lands, especially if the topic is sensitive.
Positive Feedback Examples to Inspire Your Team
When most people think about feedback, they focus on what needs to be corrected. But reinforcing the things that are already going well with positive feedback is just as important, sometimes even more so.
I’ll go back to Jake. After he stepped into those more complex sales conversations, he came to a big meeting fully prepared. He understood the contract language. He had a clear view of what the client cared about. He knew what questions to ask and how to position the offer. He showed up sharp.
After the meeting, I didn’t just say, “Nice job.” I asked, “What did you do that allowed you to understand the contract so well? What helped you think through the client’s perspective the way you did?” He told me about the prep work he’d done. So I said, “Good job with that process.” I wasn’t just praising the result. I was reinforcing the steps that led to it.
That’s the key to good positive feedback. Don’t stop at the outcome. Go one layer deeper. Call out what the person actually did that made it successful.
Try saying things like:
I’ll go back to Jake. After he stepped into those more complex sales conversations, he came to a big meeting fully prepared. He understood the contract language. He had a clear view of what the client cared about. He knew what questions to ask and how to position the offer. He showed up sharp.
After the meeting, I didn’t just say, “Nice job.” I asked, “What did you do that allowed you to understand the contract so well? What helped you think through the client’s perspective the way you did?” He told me about the prep work he’d done. So I said, “Good job with that process.” I wasn’t just praising the result. I was reinforcing the steps that led to it.
That’s the key to good positive feedback. Don’t stop at the outcome. Go one layer deeper. Call out what the person actually did that made it successful.
Try saying things like:
- “What was your process here?”
- “What led you to make that choice?”
- “Nice job preparing, especially how you anticipated their concerns.”
When you do that, people aren’t just told they did well. They start to understand exactly how they did well. And that’s what makes it repeatable.
This kind of positive reinforcement pays off. Research from SHRM shows that teams that receive feedback focused on their strengths are 12.5% more productive and nearly 9% more profitable than teams that don't.
“Negative Feedback” Examples That Actually Help People Grow
Although the phrase “negative feedback” comes up a lot, I don’t love it. It implies that the feedback is unhelpful or critical just for the sake of it. In reality, if the goal is to help someone grow, then it’s not negative but constructive. Even if the topic is uncomfortable, even if the tone is direct, the purpose is still development.
Some situations do call for tough conversations. Maybe someone shows up late all the time. Maybe their attitude in the break room drags the team down. Maybe they’re not taking care of basic hygiene, and it’s affecting how others interact with them. These aren’t easy things to talk about, but that doesn’t mean you avoid them.
What matters is how you frame it.
If someone is always late, I might say, “We can’t hand you more responsibility if we don’t trust that you’ll show up on time.” If they’re bringing negative energy to the team, I might say, “You’re not going to be seen as a leader if your presence brings people down.” If hygiene is an issue, it’s fair to say, “You won’t earn your peers’ respect if they’re constantly distracted by something that’s easy to fix.”
Those things feel personal, but they’re not insults. They’re professional feedback about patterns that are holding someone back. When you tie the message to what’s in it for them (like growth, trust, promotion, or more opportunity), it becomes something they can act on. You’re showing them the path forward, not just pointing out a flaw.
In some industries, like the trades, the tone might be more blunt. That doesn’t make it “negative”. That’s just the style of communication that works. You adjust your delivery so the message is heard. That’s part of emotional intelligence. You don’t soften the message to the point where it gets lost. But you also don’t use directness as an excuse to be careless.
The goal isn’t to tear someone down. The goal is to make it clear that something needs to change, and to help them see why it matters.
Feedback Strategies for Effective Leadership
There’s no single formula for feedback that works in every situation, but there are some key strategies that make a big difference. Most of it comes down to being specific, being intentional, and focusing on what helps the other person grow.
First, be clear about what happened. “You were late on Monday the third” is helpful. “You’re always late” isn’t. Vague feedback just creates confusion or defensiveness. The more specific you are (dates, examples, even names), the more useful your feedback becomes.
It helps to take notes over time. Most leaders don’t do this, but it’s one of the easiest ways to improve the quality of your feedback. When you write things down, you spot patterns. You bring real data to the conversation. And you avoid relying on memory, which is often incomplete or biased.
Another simple but powerful strategy is to ask for permission. Say something like, “Do I have your permission to share something I think could help you?” or “Are you open to some feedback on this?” It lowers the other person’s defenses and makes it more likely that they’ll actually listen.
You can also ask, “How do you prefer to receive feedback?” While learning styles may not impact how someone absorbs information, asking that question builds trust. It shows that you’re being thoughtful, and that helps people open up.
When it’s time to give feedback, I recommend a simple four-step process:
- Take good notes. Capture what you’re seeing as it happens, so you’re not relying on memory later.
- Enroll the person. Make it clear why this feedback matters to them. Help them see what’s in it for their growth or success.
- Tie it to expectations. Don’t just point out what isn’t working. Be clear about what needs to happen instead.
- Hold them accountable. Check back in. Follow through. Let them know you’re paying attention and supporting their progress.
You also need to calibrate your tone to the person and the setting. Being overly neutral or overly polished can actually backfire in some environments. In the trades, for example, direct talk is the norm. If you sugarcoat everything, people may not take you seriously. On the other hand, in more corporate settings, tone might matter just as much as content. You need to know your audience and adjust accordingly.
And remember, it’s okay if your feedback style as a leader looks different from how your team gives it back to you. Maybe you give feedback more informally, while they offer it in more structured ways. That’s fine. What matters is that the conversation is happening and that people know what’s expected.
Want to hear what this looks like in action? Check out this episode of The Leadership Unplugged, where we share one simple shift that helped a leader finally get their feedback to land. You’ll learn how to enroll someone in the conversation, tie feedback to what actually motivates them, and lead with clarity instead of conflict.
Giving and Receiving Feedback Activity for Leaders
One of the best ways to build skill and confidence with feedback is to practice. You don’t have to turn it into a formal training session. Just use real conversations as a chance to build the habit. Here’s a simple activity I recommend.
Start by asking for permission to coach. Say, “Would it be alright to point out something that might help you improve?” You can also ask, “Are you open to some feedback?” These are low-pressure questions that give the other person a moment to lean in. They’re not just about politeness. They shift the tone of the conversation and reduce defensiveness.
If you want to take it further, try a peer feedback role-play. Have each person take turns sharing one piece of feedback. Focus on something they’ve noticed that could help the other person grow. Keep it short and focused on one behavior. Then switch roles. This doesn’t have to be a formal workshop. You can practice it with a peer or even debrief a real interaction afterward.
Another activity to try: ask your team members how they prefer to receive feedback. Some might say they learn better through examples. Others might prefer direct conversation. Whether or not their answer reflects how they actually learn, it helps them feel heard and respected. And that makes them more receptive.
Again, this isn’t about tailoring every word to a learning style. It’s about reducing resistance. When people feel like you care enough to ask how they prefer to be coached, they’re more likely to take the feedback seriously.
Overall, practice, permission, and curiosity go a long way. These are the habits that help you build feedback into the rhythm of leadership, not just something you save for reviews.
Start by asking for permission to coach. Say, “Would it be alright to point out something that might help you improve?” You can also ask, “Are you open to some feedback?” These are low-pressure questions that give the other person a moment to lean in. They’re not just about politeness. They shift the tone of the conversation and reduce defensiveness.
If you want to take it further, try a peer feedback role-play. Have each person take turns sharing one piece of feedback. Focus on something they’ve noticed that could help the other person grow. Keep it short and focused on one behavior. Then switch roles. This doesn’t have to be a formal workshop. You can practice it with a peer or even debrief a real interaction afterward.
Another activity to try: ask your team members how they prefer to receive feedback. Some might say they learn better through examples. Others might prefer direct conversation. Whether or not their answer reflects how they actually learn, it helps them feel heard and respected. And that makes them more receptive.
Again, this isn’t about tailoring every word to a learning style. It’s about reducing resistance. When people feel like you care enough to ask how they prefer to be coached, they’re more likely to take the feedback seriously.
Overall, practice, permission, and curiosity go a long way. These are the habits that help you build feedback into the rhythm of leadership, not just something you save for reviews.
Preparing for Effective Employee Feedback Conversations
You might need to prepare more in the beginning for your feedback to be effective. That’s totally normal. Once you’ve practiced enough, the process becomes more natural. But at first, preparation is what makes the difference between a helpful conversation and a confusing one.
Start by getting clear on your intent. What do you want the other person to take away? What change are you hoping to see? If you can’t answer that, it may be too soon to give the feedback.
Next, focus on specifics. One clear, recent example is far more useful than a vague pattern. “You jumped in before Sarah could respond during Monday’s client call” is much easier to work with than “You interrupt people too much.”
Then, connect the feedback to something that matters to the employee. You’re not just pointing out an issue. You’re helping them show up more effectively, grow in their role, or earn more trust with the team. Make sure that the benefit comes through.
For personal topics, keep the focus on professional impact. You’re not making a judgment. You’re pointing out something that’s getting in their way.
Finally, always tie your feedback back to clear expectations. This is what turns a critique into a useful course correction. And if expectations weren’t clearly set, this is a good opportunity to do that now.
If you need help with that step, check out our blog on setting clear expectations, which goes hand in hand with this kind of conversation.
Start by getting clear on your intent. What do you want the other person to take away? What change are you hoping to see? If you can’t answer that, it may be too soon to give the feedback.
Next, focus on specifics. One clear, recent example is far more useful than a vague pattern. “You jumped in before Sarah could respond during Monday’s client call” is much easier to work with than “You interrupt people too much.”
Then, connect the feedback to something that matters to the employee. You’re not just pointing out an issue. You’re helping them show up more effectively, grow in their role, or earn more trust with the team. Make sure that the benefit comes through.
For personal topics, keep the focus on professional impact. You’re not making a judgment. You’re pointing out something that’s getting in their way.
Finally, always tie your feedback back to clear expectations. This is what turns a critique into a useful course correction. And if expectations weren’t clearly set, this is a good opportunity to do that now.
If you need help with that step, check out our blog on setting clear expectations, which goes hand in hand with this kind of conversation.
How to Create Healthy Feedback Culture as a Leader
You don’t build a feedback culture by handing out more feedback. You build it by making feedback part of how your team works together. Not just something that happens during reviews or when there’s a problem.
That starts with trust. If people believe you have their best interests in mind, they’re more likely to hear what you’re saying. If they don’t, even well-worded feedback will fall flat.
You also have to normalize the rhythm. That means giving feedback consistently, in real time, without turning it into a big production. A quick comment after a meeting. A check-in midweek. A note of appreciation or a small correction. These small moments add up.
That starts with trust. If people believe you have their best interests in mind, they’re more likely to hear what you’re saying. If they don’t, even well-worded feedback will fall flat.
You also have to normalize the rhythm. That means giving feedback consistently, in real time, without turning it into a big production. A quick comment after a meeting. A check-in midweek. A note of appreciation or a small correction. These small moments add up.
A healthy feedback culture is two-way, but it doesn’t have to be perfectly balanced. You can give more than you receive and still model openness. What matters is that your team knows their voice is welcome, and that they see you take action when they offer input.
When you ask for feedback, keep it simple. Questions like:
- “What’s one thing I could do better this month?”
- “What’s getting in your way that I might not see?”
Those are invitations, not tests. And when people respond, the way you handle it sets the tone. Defensiveness kills feedback culture. Curiosity builds it.
Over time, this becomes a norm. People stop waiting for permission to speak up. They give each other feedback without fear. And they see it as a path to getting better, not just something to survive.
Conclusion: Learn How to Navigate Various Types of Feedback
The best leaders don’t just give feedback but create environments where feedback is normal, useful, and trusted.
Whether you’re offering praise, correction, or coaching, the goal is always the same: to help someone grow. That means choosing the right type of feedback for the moment, being clear about what needs to change, and making sure the message is actually heard.
Just remember to keep it simple, stay specific, and focus on what helps the other person move forward.
You can get better at giving feedback the same way people get better at anything else: by practicing. Talk with other leaders. Role-play real scenarios. Ask for feedback on how you give feedback.
If you want a place to start, check out our free Language of Leadership course preview. It’s built to help you improve the way you give and receive feedback so you can lead with more clarity, confidence, and impact.
Start practicing with us today and turn feedback into one of your most reliable leadership tools.
Whether you’re offering praise, correction, or coaching, the goal is always the same: to help someone grow. That means choosing the right type of feedback for the moment, being clear about what needs to change, and making sure the message is actually heard.
Just remember to keep it simple, stay specific, and focus on what helps the other person move forward.
You can get better at giving feedback the same way people get better at anything else: by practicing. Talk with other leaders. Role-play real scenarios. Ask for feedback on how you give feedback.
If you want a place to start, check out our free Language of Leadership course preview. It’s built to help you improve the way you give and receive feedback so you can lead with more clarity, confidence, and impact.
Start practicing with us today and turn feedback into one of your most reliable leadership tools.
Download The Free eBook and never worry about excuses again!
The eBook is on its way to your inbox!